Sorrento man found not guilty of possessing child pornography

Judge deems evidence obtained from laptop without warrant inadmissible.

The trial of a Notch Hill man accused of possessing and accessing child pornography quickly drew to a close after the judge ruled police had violated his rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

As well as charges of possessing and accessing child pornography, Charles Gleave, 77, was facing one count of flight from a police officer and one count of obstruction of a police officer in the course of their duties.

He was found not guilty of all four charges in BC Supreme Court in Salmon Arm Friday.

The trial ended after Justice Hope Hyslop ruled on a voir dire – or a trial within a trial – in which she was asked to determine whether evidence police had obtained during a search of Gleave’s truck and laptop computer was admissible. She ruled it was not.

“What the judge said very much parallels what we submitted to the court. You can’t search computers without a warrant,” remarked Gleave’s defence lawyer Glenn Verdurmen following the judge’s decision.

He noted the case is interesting because it addresses privacy rights regarding evolving technology such as laptops and phones.

Justice Hyslop had agreed with the defence that the administration of justice would be brought into disrepute by including the evidence, based on the charter violations of unreasonable search and seizure and being arbitrarily detained or imprisoned.

Gleave was arrested shortly after midnight on March 31, 2014 after police were advised of a suspicious vehicle in the parking lot of the Sorrento fire hall.

When a police officer drove up behind Gleave’s truck and turned on the vehicle’s emergency lights, the court heard that Gleave drove away slightly faster than walking speed for about 50 metres. He stopped within two feet of another police vehicle that had blocked the road.

During Friday’s proceedings, after the judge dismissed the evidence for the child pornography charges, she dealt with the remaining two counts.

Crown counsel Mariane Armstrong told the court that Gleave’s obligation when the officer came up behind him was to stop, but he didn’t do so.

Verdurmen suggested that Gleave’s driving at a slow speed for a relatively short distance could be consistent with him wanting to get out of the path of an emergency vehicle.

The judge concluded that the Crown had not made its case and found Gleave not guilty of the remaining two charges: flight from and obstruction of a police officer.


Just Posted

Salmon Arm makeup artist adds new sparkle to industry

Missy MacKintosh launches her own cosmetics company with the release of biodegradable glitter

Blind Bay shooter changes story about accomplice

Jordan Barnes tells the court he was sole person responsible for death of Nicholas Larsen

Okanagan realtors add voices to anti-speculation tax coalition

This speculation tax is likely to harm the very people the government is trying to protect

Askew’s owner objects to underpass

Downtown Salmon Arm voices its support for project, which will go to referendum in October

MMIW drone team fundraising for summer searches

Organizers expect the searches to expand this summer

Toronto van attack suspect faces 10 counts of first-degree murder

The suspect in the Toronto van attack that killed 10 people and injured 15 others on Monday is a 25-year-old man named Alek Minassian

‘Enough is enough’: G7 ministers agree to call Russia out

‘Enough is enough’: G7 ministers agree to call Russia out on ‘malign’ behaviour

Cosby jury to decide: Serial rapist or con artist’s mark

Bill Cosby is at the courthouse Tuesday morning ahead of closing arguments in his sexual assault retrial.

Trump: ‘Our hearts are with the grieving families in Canada’

U.S. President Donald Trump is offering his condolences to Canadians

Trudeau calls van attack ‘horrific and senseless’

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau calls van attack ‘horrific and senseless,’ says no apparent terror link

Officer’s actions ‘one shining moment’ after Toronto van attack

Arresting officer’s actions ‘one shining moment’ in the wake of Toronto van attack

Painting of Enderby landmark finds home in Victoria

Royal BC Museum adds, from Grafton Tyler Brown collection, work of Enderby Cliffs

Judith Guichon steps down as Lieutenant Governor of B.C.

Election decision didn’t make her best moments from the past six years

Okanagan Lake levels stay steady but snowpack is growing: officials

Whether or not the tributaries and creeks flood depends on how suddenly the snowpack begins to melt,

Most Read