A civil court case over well water on a pair of rural Shuswap properties was heard in B.C. Supreme Court (Black Press Media files)

A civil court case over well water on a pair of rural Shuswap properties was heard in B.C. Supreme Court (Black Press Media files)

B.C. Supreme Court dismisses claim over well water on rural Shuswap properties

Fraudulent misrepresentation, breach of contract and other allegations dismissed by judge.

A Supreme Court of B.C. judge did not find enough merit in a Shuswap couple’s arguments in regards to water they had been receiving from a neighbouring property to award them the legal easement and damages they were seeking.

The matter was decided on March 24 after the judge heard arguments over seven days in January. The case was initiated by Yvonne Kleineniggenkemper and Norbert Hustemeier‑Hennig who bought their rural Shuswap property from Siegfried and Erika Spieker, the owners of an adjacent property, in 2010.

Prior to the sale, both the Spiekers’ home and the property which the plaintiffs would go on to buy were supplied by a drilled well and another water source referred to in court documents as “the Metcalfe source.” The drilled well was on the plaintiffs’ property and the Metcalfe source was on the defendants’ land.

Court documents note the plaintiffs were German nationals and had limited English skills when they were searching for property to purchase before moving to Canada. They engaged the services of a German-speaking realtor to help them buy in Canada. The Spiekers also spoke fluent German and much of the discussion of the purchase over the course of two visits to the property was conducted in German.

All parties agree that discussion before an offer to purchase included a promise of continued access to the Metcalfe source, which brought water to their property through a system of pipes and information on the drilled well’s limited quantity of water.

The court documents state clauses in the offer making sale subject to professional review of water and sewer were considered unnecessary and removed by the plaintiffs prior to submitting it to the owner. The court heard that the sale went through and both parties became close friends over the following five years. The arrangement of providing water through the pipes proceeded.

In 2015, the Spiekers began the process of selling their property and accepted a purchase offer which was made conditional on cutting water supply off to neighbouring properties. This left the plaintiffs reliant on water from the drilled well on their property which did not provide enough water for their home. They attempted to drill other wells but none succeeded.

The plaintiffs filed a notice of civil claim (NOCC) against the couple who sold them their property and a Real Estate agent involved in the transaction, alleging fraudulent misrepresentation, breach of contract, negligent misrepresentation and proprietary estoppel. They based their allegations on verbal exchanges prior to the sale and a document called a property disclosure statement filed by the sellers.

The plaintiffs sought damages and a court-ordered easement allowing them to draw water from the Metcalfe source again.

The Judge did not rule in favour of the plaintiffs on any of their claims.

The decision concluded by stating that the plaintiffs failed to establish any of the claims advanced in the NOCC against the defendants. The plaintiffs didn’t proceed with their claim against the defendants’ realtor and it was also dismissed.



jim.elliot@saobserver.net

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Court

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

B.C's COVID-19 dashboard shows the peaks and valleys of cases prior to the record daily report of 132 on April 9, 2021. (Dashboard image)
Interior Health has record day of COVID-19 cases

132 cases reported Friday, April 9, more deaths in Vernon hospital outbreak

School District 83 trustees are leaning towards an option in the school district’s Long Range Facilities Plan that favours making Salmon Arm Secondary’s Sullivan campus and Jackson campus (pictured) both Grade 9-12 schools. (Google maps image)
Letter: Two high school option for Salmon Arm will create ‘have, have not’ situation

Writer concerned with E5 option, says transparent talk about implications needed

Left, Elena Bruns (2015 Rapattack Junior recruit/current Rapattack staff) and Leah Nash (2019 Rapattack Junior recruit/current Rapattack staff) in a helicopter on the Eagle Bluff Fire, August 2019. (Kamloops Fire Centre photo)
Salmon Arm students stick with wildfire fighting after junior Rapattack program

Junior Fire Crew program partners with Salmon Arm Secondary, develops students’ love for job

Work began April 6, 2021 on the Trans-Canada Highway downtown corridor project to improve safety and traffic flow, which will see the traffic light at Ross Street relocated to Fourth Street NE. (Martha Wickett - Salmon Arm Observer)
VIDEO: Traffic slow downs to go through May on Salmon Arm highway corridor

Ministry says night work not planned on Highway 1, single lanes to remain as traffic light changed

Genevieve Reynard dances as a video is recorded to be judged at a Kamloops-based dance festival. She earned first and second place honours in a variety of styles. (Shuswap Dance Center/Facebook)
Shuswap Dance Center dancers win big in Kamloops competition

Thirty-five young competitors place in top three in either solo or group number

B.C. Health Minister Adrian Dix and Premier John Horgan describe vaccine rollout at the legislature, March 29, 2021. (B.C. government)
1,262 more COVID-19 infections in B.C. Friday, 9,574 active cases

Province’s mass vaccination reaches one million people

Vernon Secondary School. (Google Maps)
Case of COVID-19 at North Okanagan high school

VSS exposure announced late Friday, April 9

The Royal’s 1951 visit to Revelstoke. (Photo by Revelstoke Museum and Archives #17)
PHOTOS: Prince Philip visited Revelstoke – twice

The prince died April 9 at the age of 99

Nolan's Pharmasave in downtown Vernon received 200 AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccines Friday, April 9, 2021. (Brendan Shykora - Morning Star)
AstraZeneca vaccines arrive at Vernon pharmacies

Four pharmacies in the city received doses of the COVID-19 inoculant Friday

The RCMP were called to the Alchemy Studio on Thursday, April 8. (Contributed)
Revelstoke yoga class fined for defying COVID-19 orders

The RCMP were called to the Alchemy Studio on April 8

An East Hill resident had their leaf bags torched in front of their home overnight April 8. Less than two weeks prior their garbage can was lit on fire too. (Taryn Allen photo)
Garbage, leaf fires spark fear in North Okanagan

First an East Hill residents’ trash can, then bagged leaves were lit on fire

Okanagan-based All Are Family Outreach Society, which provides support to those struggling from Armstrong to Kelowna, is in need of a new headquarters after leaving a Winfield church in June 2020. (All Are Family Outreach photo)
Okanagan outreach society in ‘desperate’ need after storage unit break-in

All Are Family Outreach had $4,000 in tools stolen from its donation shipping container

A large illuminated heart was installed on the roof of the Vernon Jubilee Hospital May 1, 2020. (VJH Foundation photo)
Three deaths linked to COVID-19 outbreak in Vernon hospital

Interior Health reports two additional deaths at VJH

Most Read