Salmon Arm seniors protest DriveABLE policies

Seniors think the testing and the process cause a lot of undue stress and do not provide a true accounting of their abilities.

Angered octogenarians: A group of concerned Salmon Arm seniors look at the BC Driving Regulations on the computer.

Aging can bring with it difficult transitions – and a group of Shuswap-area seniors thinks government driving regulations are both creating and exacerbating difficulties for some seniors.

Chuck MacDonald would like seniors to be aware of what might await them and would like those in positions of power over drivers to consider the results of their decisions.

“Victoria makes arbitrary decisions and we, as seniors, should be aware of how they’re going to affect us, and so should the advisors – doctors, cops and others – to Victoria…,” he says.

MacDonald is referring to regulations in effect for drivers as they turn 80.

“In smaller areas like Salmon Arm, if you lose your mode of transportation, it can be devastating. We’re encouraged to stay in our homes, but if you’ve lost permission to drive, how do you stay there, and if you can’t stay there, where do you go?”

He and several other seniors think the testing and the way the process is administered cause a lot of undue stress, are not senior friendly, and do not provide a true accounting of their abilities.

Steve Martin, B.C.’s superintendent of motor vehicles, outlines the current requirements regarding older drivers.

•At age 80 and every two years after that, he says, people are required to have a driver’s medical examination, which is carried out by a doctor and tests physical and cognitive abilities. The province provides $75 to doctors for the exam, but some doctors charge a fee over and above that.

•The standardized report is sent to the superintendent’s office and its team of nurses, who decide if any follow-up testing is necessary.

“Sometimes we get a report that clearly indicates a major concern. At that point, somebody’s driving privileges could be rescinded,” Martin says. If there are no concerns, the driver carries on as normal.

•If some concerns about a driver’s cognitive abilities are raised, the superintendent’s office will send the driver a letter requiring them to undertake an in-office ‘DriveABLE’ assessment, which is a cognitive test done using a computer screen.

“They have to touch the computer screen in response to things that are being presented,” Martin says.

People from Salmon Arm have been instructed to go to Kelowna for both the DriveABLE computer assessment and the road test, which may be required later. If the driver fails or passes the DriveABLE assessment, they don’t take a road test. The failed driver will no longer be able to drive, whereas the driver who passes can continue.

•“If they score in the middle zone – not a clear pass and not a clear fail – we refer people to an on-road assessment,” Martin says.

The on-road assessment is not done in the senior’s own car but in one that has, for safety reason, dual controls, he explains.

Martin says only a small percentage of seniors who go for the initial driver’s medical examination end up having further testing.

“We assess 44,000 seniors every year and only 1,500 of those are referred to DriveABLE.”

However, that’s small consolation to Salmon Arm seniors Chuck and Joyce MacDonald, Boyd Greer, Fred and Vivian MacDonald, and Joe and Jenny Veldhoen. Although they understand that unsafe drivers shouldn’t be driving, they disagree with the process. Vivian MacDonald went to a doctor after receiving the letter saying she would have to have a medical. She expected just a physical exam.

“All I did was pay $50, he asked me all these questions and by this time I was frazzled,” she recalls, noting that the doctor then took her blood pressure which was high. “I just froze. I couldn’t think. I came out of there so frustrated. I don’t think older people should be put through this.”

She also felt badly and under pressure being in the doctor’s office, trying to recall items on a grocery list the doctor had recited to her, while the waiting room was filled with sick people,

Joe Veldhoen says he first received a notice to see a doctor in early October and he’s still not done with the process. He, too, didn’t like the computer test, finding the glare of the screen and the format unsettling. After taking all the required tests he was given back his licence, but he still hasn’t received the letter he expected confirming everything’s official.

“It comes out of the blue,” says his spouse Jenny of the requirements. “You can’t sleep anymore, thinking about it.”

Joe agrees.

“They make all this to-do about elder abuse. I think they’re doing a good job themselves.”

Greer points out that so much is at a doctor’s discretion, he’d like the motor vehicle branch to handle the exam.

Says Chuck MacDonald: “We want a realistic test, a better test, better treatment and more consideration.”

Superintendent Martin, meanwhile, says the DriveABLE test is scientifically proven and the computer procedure is similar to what people are used to when taking eye exams. He did say, however, that his office will be striving to better communicate with seniors and to explain the process better.

“We need to balance the need for public safety and the need for people’s mobility. We do try to keep people driving as long as they can, within the context of safety.”


Editor’s note: On Monday afternoon, the B.C. government announced it would no longer use the DriveABLE program as a sole factor in revoking a licence. The Observer will provide an update as details become available.

Just Posted

Okanagan Air Cadet challenges cadet program on gendered policy

He wants the policy to be more gender inclusive

Okanagan-Shuswap Weather: Summer sun for Sunday

The forecast for the week ahead shows some rain but plenty of sun and warm tempertures.

In photos: Uptown Askew’s Family Day

The Uptown Askew’s Family Day event was filled with classic cars, face… Continue reading

CSRD to support cannabis growth in agricultural zones

Regional district revision brings policy in line with Agricultural Land Commission

Word on the street: Has the wet July weather put a damper on your summer any?

Due to the wetter-than-usual July weather, the Observer asked: Has the wet… Continue reading

July showers wash out half of the Okanagan’s cherry crop

Cherry growers say this is the worst season they’ve seen in decades

Fire department helps with body recovery in Okanagan Lake

Penticton fire department assisted the RCMP with the recovery of a body Saturday

Police on scene at Penticton beach

RCMP were at a what is believed to be a crime scene near Skaha Beach Sunday

Community service ordered for Princeton man who stole from firefighters

A young man who stole food and money from the Princeton Volunteer… Continue reading

Okanagan rainbow crosswalk defaced

Vandals cover colours with white paint in District of Coldstream sometime overnight Saturday

B.C. VIEWS: NDP pushes ahead with Crown forest redistribution

This isn’t the time for a radical Indigenous rights agenda

Two dead in two-vehicle crash between Revelstoke and Golden

RCMP are investigating the cause of the crash

Ottawa fights planned class action against RCMP for bullying, intimidation

The current case is more general, applying to employees, including men, who worked for the RCMP

Alberta judge denies B.C.’s bid to block ‘Turn Off the Taps’ bill

He said the proper venue for the disagreement is Federal Court

Most Read